Bishops, Overseers, Presbyters, and Elders
[Home][Contacts][Comparisons]

 

This is a study of the word bishop as it appears in 1 Timothy 3: 1, 2.In the various versions, other words are substituted for bishop. The whole chapter deals withthe qualifications of bishops and deacons in the New Testament church. Only the first twoqualifications are included in this study as the primary interest here is the use of the word'bishop' and its substitutes. The renderings of twenty-three versions are listed here. Otherversions use these terms and the wording of the qualifications. Explanations from thirteenversions and four other reference books follow these. Then, there is a commentary on what hasbeen written.


Versions Compared

 

ANT Authentic New TestamentNET New Evangelical Translation
BNT Barclay New TestamentNJB New Jerusalem Bible
CENT Common English New TestamentNSNT Norlie's Simplified New Testament
CEV Contemporary English VersionPRS Phillips Revised Student Edition
CJB Complete Jewish BibleSGAT An American Translation (Smith-Goodspeed)
CTNT Centenary Translation of the New TestamentTCNT The Twentieth Century New Testament
EVD English Version for the DeafTEV Today's English Version
KJV King James VersionTJB Jerusalem Bible (Catholic)
KLNT Kleist-Lilly New TestamentTM The Message
KTC Knox TranslationWNT Williams New Testament
MSNT The Modern Speech New TestamentYLR Young's Literal Revised Edition
NEB New English Bible

 

Other Versions Used

 

CNT Cassirer New TestamentNCV New Century Version
LB Living BibleWAS Worrell New Testament
NBV New Berkeley Version


1 Timothy3: 1, 2
ANT ..., 'If anyone aspires to be a supervisor he desires honourable employment.'The supervisor ought therefore to be irreproachable, husband of one wife, ... .
BNT ..., that to be ambitious to be the leader and guardian of the community is to set one'sheart on a noble task. The superintendent of the community must therefore be a man whom noone can criticize. He must be the faithful husband of one wife.
CENT ..., if anyone desires the office of overseer, he desires a good work. The overseer thenmust be blameless, the husband of one wife, ... .
CEV It is true that anyone who desires to be a church official wants to be somethingworthwhile. That's why officials must have a good reputation and be married only once.
CJB ...: anyone aspiring to be a congregation leader is seeking worthwhile work. Acongregation leader must be above reproach, he must be faithful to his wife, ... .
CTNT ..., "If any man is seeking the office of a minister he is aspiring to do a nobletask." The minister should be a man of blameless character; he should be husband of butone wife; ... .
EVD ...: If a person is trying hard to become an elder, that person is wanting a good work.An elder must be good enough that people cannot rightly criticize him. He must have onlyone wife.
KJV ..., If a man desire the office of a bishop, he desireth a good work.
A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, ... .
KLNT ...: "If anyone is eager for the office of bishop, he desires a noble post." Abishop, then, must be blameless, married only once, ... .
KTC ..., When a man aspires to a bishopric, it is no mean employment that he covets. Theman who is to be a bishop, then, must be one with whom no fault can be found; faithful toone wife, ... .
MSNT ..., "If anyone is eager to have the oversight of a church, he desires a noble work." Aminister then must be a man of irreproachable character, true to his one wife, ... .
NEB ...: 'To aspire to leadership is an honorable ambition.' Our leader, therefore, orbishop, must be above reproach, faithful to his one wife, ... .
NET ...: If anyone sets his heart on being a spiritual leader, he desires to do a noble work.Now, a spiritual overseer must be blameless, the husband of one wife, ... .
NJB ...: to want to be a presiding elder is to desire a noble task, That is why thepresiding elder must have an impeccable character. Husband of one wife, ... .
NSNT ..., "Whoever aspires to church office seeks a noble task." The pastor should be a manof irreproachable character, and never have more than one wife.
PRS ... that a man who sets his heart on leadership has laudable ambition. Well, for theoffice of bishop a man must be of blameless reputation, he must be married to one wifeonly, ... .
SGAT ..., Whoever aspires to the office of superintendent sets his heart on a fine work.A superintendent must be a man above reproach, only once married, ... .
TCNT When a man aspires to be a Presiding-Officer in the Church, he is ambitious for a nobletask. The Presiding-Officer should be a man of blameless character; a faithful husband; ... .
TEV ...: If a man is eager to be a church leader, he desires an excellent work. A churchleader must be without fault; he must have only one wife, ... .
TJB ...: To want to be a presiding elder is to want to do a noble work. That is why thepresident must have an impeccable character. He must not have been married more thanonce, ... .
TM If anyone want to provide leadership in the church, good! But there are pre-conditions:A leader must be well-thought-of, committed to his wife, ... .
WNT ...: "Whoever aspires to the office of pastor desires an excellent work." So the pastormust be a man above reproach, must have only one wife, ... .
YLR ...: If anyone the oversight doth long for, a right work he desireth; it behoveth,therefore, the overseer to be blameless, of one wife a husband, ... .


Explanations

 

BNT The word bishop has today an ecclesiastical sound which the wordepiskopos did not have in New Testament times at all. The word literally means anoverseer or a superintendent; the oversight may be with a view to discipline or it may bewith a view to protection. Usually in New Testament times the word bishop will give a quitewrong impression of what the episkopos was. He was the superintendent of thecongregation. It has been said with truth that the word elder in the New Testamentdescribes the church leader in his person, while the word episkopos describeshim in his function.
CEV Footnote: Church official: Or "bishop."
      Married only once: Or"the husbands of only one wife" or "faithful in marriage."
CNT Footnote: Or 'pastoral leader,' or 'church leader.'
KTC Footnote: It is possible that St. Paul means us to understand these qualificationsas applying, not only to episcopal office, but to that of a priest; he does not meanpresbyters in this chapter.
      'Faithful to one wife' may mean,but does not necessarily mean, that in the discipline of the early Church a re-marriedwidower was ineligible for the episcopate.
LB Footnote: [Pastor] -- More literally, "church leader" or "presiding elder."
MSNT Minister: lit. 'one who has the oversight,' 'a bishop.' The identity of 'bishops'and 'elders' in the early church is shown by the fact that the qualifications here requiredfrom 'bishops' are substantially the same as those required from elders in Titus 1: 5-9,where indeed the word 'bishop' occurs.
NBV Footnote: "Bishop" is translated from the Greek episkopos, meaningliterally overseer. In the first century episkopos, bishop or overseer, andpresbuteros, elder, were used interchangeably, eg. Titus 1: 5 and 7, where both wordsrefer to the same office. After the first century the office of bishop or overseer over thatof elder developed.
NCV Footnote: Elder: older men who led God's people; appointed leaders in the church.
NEB Footnote: [one wife]: Or married to one wife, or married only once.
NET Footnote: Greek: "episkopos;" a term used to emphasize the supervision andguidance a church leader was to provide.
NJB Elders: After the model of the 70 elders appointed by Moses, local Jewishcommunities were governed by a committee of elders (presbuteroi). This structure wastaken over by Christian communities. Elders were carefully selected and their office was seento depend on the holy Spirit. The president (episkopos) was probably chosen from amongthem. (Exodus 18:13; Acts 11:30; Acts 14:23; Acts 20:28; Titus 1:5-9).
TEV Footnote: have only one wife, or be married only once.
WAS Footnote: A bishop: an overseer or pastor of an assembly.

Greek-English Lexicon (Thayer):
Episkopos: an overseer, a man charged with the duty of seeing that thingsto be done are done rightly. ...; specifically the superintendent, head, oroverseer of any Christian church; Acts 20: 28; Philippians 1: 1; 1 Timothy 3: 2;Titus 1: 7.

Halley's Bible Handbook:
Bishops and Deacons: Their qualifications (1-16). Probably intended as an ideal, nota legal enactment. "One wife" (2), probably meant to exclude, not single men, but polygamists.Paul was a single man.

Smith's Bible Dictionary:
Bishop. The word originally signified an "overseer" or spiritual superintendent.The titles bishop and elder, or presbyter, were essentially equivalent. Bishop is from theGreek, and denotes one who exercises the function of overseeing. Presbyter was derivedfrom the office in the synagogue. Of the order in which the first elders or bishopswere appointed, as of the occasion which led to the institution of the office, we have norecord. The duties of the bishop-elders appear to have been as follows: 1. Generalsuperintendence over the spiritual well-being of the flock (1 Peter 5: 2). 2. The work ofteaching, both publicly and privately (1 Thessalonians 5: 12; Titus 1: 9; 1 Timothy 5: 17). 3.The work of visiting the sick (James 5: 14). 4. Among other acts of charity, that ofreceiving strangers occupied a conspicuous place (1 Timothy 3: 2; Titus 1: 8). Peter callsChrist "the shepherd and bishop of your souls" (1 Peter 2: 25).

Vine's Complete Expository Dictionary of Old and New Testament Words:
Episkopos, lit. an overseer, whence English "bishop," which has precisely the samemeaning, is found in Acts 20: 28; Philippians 1: 1; 1 Timothy 3: 2; Titus 1: 7; 1 Peter 2: 25.Note: Presbuteros, "an elder," is another term for the same person as bishop oroverseer. See Acts 20: 17 with verse 28. The term "elder" indicates the mature spiritualexperience and understanding of those so described; the term "bishop," or "overseer,"indicates the character of the work undertaken. According to the divine will and appointment,as in the NT, there were to be "bishops" in every local church, Acts 14: 23; Acts 20: 17;Philippians 1: 1; Titus 1: 5; James 5: 14.


Commentary

 

There is much general agreement; yet there are variations. While there aredefinite statements, there is an element of uncertainty in numerous cases.

The following words used seem to be virtually synonymous as used in thispassage. These are: bishop, overseer, elder, superintendent, pastor, presbyter, leader,supervisor, minister, and spiritual leader. The first three of these terms seem to be themost commonly used ones. Generally speaking, the term bishop was used to describethe office. The term elder was used to describe the man. He was usually an older,experienced man of high moral character. The elder, or bishop, in most of the versions, wasthe spiritual leader of the church. A few suggest only a church leader who may or may nothave been what is known today as a minister or pastor. Since the word bishop in somechurches today suggests not a local leader, but a regional leader, it is apparent that thosechurches have changed the position and function of a bishop.

This is a position to which a man would aspire. Thus, he could choose toprepare himself for the position. However, first he must meet certain qualifications. Then,he must be appropriately appointed. It was considered good by Paul that a man should desirethis position. Although some versions may hint that the man could desire the position forhis own purposes, most imply that it was for the benefit of service to the community in thehonor of the Yahshua.

Only two of the qualifications of a bishop are mentioned in the passageunder consideration in this essay. All versions stress that he should be without reproach.This would be appropriate for a man of his position. He was chosen from the congregationafter divine approval had been sought. Nothing is said about formal education. The secondqualification gives different assumptions in the various versions. The main stress seems tobe that he was not to be in a polygamous marital state. Since the wife is mentioned, thebishop would have to be a man. Also, he should be married, although one version stressesthat the wording does not eliminate single men from holding this office. A few versionssuggest that men who have been widowed or divorced could not hold this office.

Today, the various churches use these terms to name the position of thespiritual leader of a congregation. Although pastor and minister are the most common, otherslisted in these versions include bishop, presiding elder, and overseer. Thus, the churcheswhich use one of these terms to name the spiritual leader are correct. Those using the termsfor other church officers or using other terms for this position may not be correct.

The whole chapter refers to bishops and deacons only. Thus, these must havebeen the two basic offices for the ministry and care of the early Christian church. Allother names used today have been added by man. Is it important what the names of the officersare? Has the church grown such that man has been authorized to create a hierarchy or newpositions? Has Yahshua authorized the changes? If so, why has He done so? If not, can anychurch that has other positions and functions justly claim to be the church of Yahshua?Are women, unmarried men, divorced men, or widowed men, all of whom we see in the positionof local spiritual leader in today's church, really legitimate in their positions? How manychurches today use the same standards that Paul advocated when they choose who will serveas congregational leaders? I leave the reader to consider these questions in regard to thedenomination of which he/she claims to be a member.